Garth's Auctions Inc., OH - Read over 373 Reviews from Customers
logo

Bidder Reviews for Garth's Auctions Inc. (373)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 373 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

Robert
Cold Spring, NY

Jan 07, 2024
A professional company
Every thing went smoothly:)
Report
THREE AMERICAN PAINTED FRAMES.

Vincent
N Hollywood, CA

Aug 21, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Aug 23, 2023
Thank you for your review, Vincent! We hope you bid with us again soon!

John
Newbury, MA

Aug 21, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Aug 21, 2023
Thank you for the review and your feedback about what we can improve. We appreciate you taking the time to let us know.
PAIR OF WOODEN SHOE PROTECTORS OR PATTENS.

Jw
Snellville, GA

Aug 20, 2023
Excellent Auction House
This was a very smooth and timely transaction and that is much appreciated.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Aug 21, 2023
Thank you for the 5-star review and for your business!
AMERICAN STONEWARE DISH AND JUG.

John
Pine Bush, NY

Aug 06, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Aug 07, 2023
Thank you for buying with us and for the review, John.
PAIR OF CANDLESTICKS SIGNED "AVIGDOR".

William
Maple Plain, MN

Aug 02, 2023
Great overall experience and customer service!
My second time buying from Garth's and it was another great experience. Accurate pictures and description, very friendly customer service. They no longer offer in-house shipping, so unfortunately the shipping cost is about 2X what is used to be, but that's the only negative. Will continue to follow and buy from Garths.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Aug 03, 2023
Thank you for the review, William! We appreciate you being a return buyer!
GROUP OF ANGLER'S PRIDE "BENO" LURES.

Arthur
Lynnfield, MA

Aug 01, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Aug 03, 2023
Thank you for the review!
TWO CHILMARK CONFEDERATE GENERALS, FRANCIS BARNUM.

Stacy
Ferndale, MI

Jul 03, 2023
First time purchase
Description and pick up was spot on.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jul 05, 2023
Welcome to Garth’s, Stacy! Thank you for bidding with us and for the great review.
SAROUK RUG.

Glenn
Hacienda Heights, CA

Jul 02, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jul 05, 2023
Thank you, Glenn
AMERICAN FRANK HOLTON SAXOPHONE.

Robert
Hampton, CT

Jul 02, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jul 05, 2023
Thank you, Robert.
AMERICAN SPOON RACK AND TWELVE COIN SILVER SPOONS.

Mark
Aventura, FL

Jul 02, 2023
Don’t do business with this auction house.
No customer device. Aweful people!!!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jul 05, 2023
Mark-you registered to bid accepting or terms and conditions including that we do not offer in-house shipping at this time. After you won a lot, you sent multiple emails asking us to ship your lot. We sent kind and clear instructions for how to arrange shipping to your own needs and preferences just like all the other purchasers in the same auction. It is a shame you chose to leave this retaliatory, negative review simply because you didn’t get your way. Thank you for your purchase. We do hope you enjoy it.
VINTAGE STERLING WINGED DEER BROOCH.

Cheryl
Columbus, OH

Jul 01, 2023
Fabulous Lotton!
Excellent transaction as always! This auction house is top notch. The vase was even more beautiful in person. I love buying from Garth's!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jul 05, 2023
Thank you for the glowing review, Cheryl. You made our day!
AMERICAN CHARLES LOTTON ART GLASS VASE.

John
Fayetteville, TN

Jun 26, 2023
Second Garth's Auction Purchase...
This is the second large and fragile antique clock that I have bought in in one of Garth's auctions... Just like the first time the clock was better than expected and it arrived in perfect condition...
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 29, 2023
Thank you, John., for your review!
AMERICAN "BIRGE, PECK AND CO." TRIPLE DECKER CLOCK

Harry
Sherman Oaks, CA

Jun 18, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 29, 2023
Thank you!
LITTLE RASCALS "TEACHER'S PET" POSTER.

Harry
Sherman Oaks, CA

Jun 18, 2023
All Items Accurately Described
I have been consistently pleased with my purchases and the customer service at Garth's Auction House. Thank you.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 29, 2023
You made our day, Harry! Thank you for the kind review of our services.
1885 BRIEF HISTORY OF THE REPUBLICAN PARTY.

Melanie
Fort Worth, TX

Jun 14, 2023
Good merchandise and service
Good merchandise
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 29, 2023
Thank you for the 5-star review, Melanie!
NAVAJO RUG.

Robert
Perrysburg, OH

Jun 12, 2023
Accuracy of product
Stay away from
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 29, 2023
Robert, our team has reached out twice (leaving voice mails) to understand the unknown issue with the lot of 100 dimes you purchased for $90 hammer. We are always happy to assist once an issue is clearly communicated and brought to our attention. Feel free to return our calls.
GROUP OF PROOF ROOSEVELT DIMES.

John
Bremen, IN

Jun 10, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 29, 2023
Thank you for review, John
HISTORICAL BLUE STAFFORDSHIRE CAPITOL PLATE.

George
Tampa, FL

May 27, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 02, 2023
Thank you, George!

Felix
Goshen, CT

May 27, 2023
Professional services
Excellent first experience, I would definitely work with them again!!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jun 02, 2023
Felix-thank you for the review! We look forward to heaving you return as a buyer!

Anthony
Brooklyn, NY

May 22, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 24, 2023
Thank you for the 5-star review, Anthony!
AMERICAN MOON CANDLE HOLDER.

Linda
Louisville, KY

May 18, 2023
Personal Touch
This is a first-class company that treats its clients with the utmost respect. It was a personal help to me in arranging the shipping, which was fast and well done. I love the piece I bought and enjoyed the auction. I follow their auctions for consistent high quality items.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 24, 2023
Thank you, Linda! We are grateful for your kind assessment of our services. Enjoy your item and bid with us again soon.
"MARECHAL FOCH" BY CHARLES ROCHER.

Cathy
Haverhill, MA

May 15, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 15, 2023
Thank you for the review, Cathy!
AMERICAN HOOKED RUG.

CATHY
Chandler, TX

May 08, 2023
There was an issue initially with receiving my auction item but they corrected the problem promptly.
There was an issue initially with receiving my auction item but they corrected the problem promptly. They even paid for the shipping cost to compensate me for the delay! They also called me twice, once to apologize for the delay and then again to make sure I got the shipment. They are family owned and really care about their customers! Thanks, Garth's Auctions!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 24, 2023
Cathy-we are so very sorry for the first mix up! Thank you for your business, allowing us to correct the problem and earning your trust. You may always count on Garth's to step up for our clients.
AMERICAN PIECED QUILT.

Trent
Kannapolis, NC

May 07, 2023
Third party shipping
Garths Auction was the standard fare, no real complaints here, but their choice of third party shipping was ridiculous. Required several emails to verify pick up, payment and a "release" consent before the shipper would retrieve the item. In house shipping is the best. Probably won't bid on third party shipping again.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 15, 2023
Trent-thank you for your feedback. We are sorry that the process was belabored with your last purchase. Our UPS shipper experienced a flood in their store in the time frame you mentioned, so things were definitely hectic and slower than our customers may normally expect. We hope to win back those three stars on another occasion. Thank you for your business.
WWII GERMAN SS ALLACH PRESENTATION PLATE.

Daniel
Prairieville, LA

May 07, 2023
UPS Store Overwhelmed
The local UPS Store took several weeks to pick up, package and ship my item. That said, it was packed extremely well. Best packing of a delicate wood carving I have ever seen.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 15, 2023
Thank you for you patience and your fine 5-star review, Daniel.
AMERICAN ROBERT FRANITA DECOY.

Bruce
Delaware, OH

May 07, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 15, 2023
Thank you for the review, Bruce!
CONCERT MODEL STRADIVARIUS VIOLIN.

Gintaras
Vilnius, LT

Apr 25, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 15, 2023
Thank you for the review.
SWISS JAEGER "LE COULTRE" ATMOS CLOCK.

George
Clifton, NJ

Apr 19, 2023
The best, professional, honest, swift service
As good as it gets. Shipping job first class
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Apr 20, 2023
Hi George! Thank you for your glowing review! We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience.
NIAGARA (20TH CENTURY FOX, 1953).

Richard
Ottawa, CA

Mar 29, 2023
Excellent items and service that went a step further!!
Thank you very much for the great items from your coin auction!! Shipping such heavy lots to Canada was a little complicated because nobody wanted to accept them. But thanks to your amazing employees, Garth's Auction Inc was able to ship them to Canada!! Thank you again for the great service and making the extra effort to go a step further for me. Much appreciated!!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Mar 29, 2023
Richard, Thank you for buying with us and singing the praises of our staff. We hope we may be of service again in the near future! Enjoy your lots!
FOUR INDIAN HEAD AND LINCOLN CENT COIN FOLDERS.

David
Fulton, MS

Mar 19, 2023
Luke Warm Experience
Note: It cost me $63.17 to ship a Quezal shade from Columbus, OH to Tupelo, MS. This is in addition to a $75.00 buyers fee to purchase a $300.00 shade. Lastly, it takes all day for your lot to come to auction. With this in mind, I'm going to limit my use of Garth's Auctions unless it's absolutely necessary.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.May 24, 2023
David-All of your concerns (shipping cost, buyers premium, and speed of sale) are the "cost and process of doing business" challenges faced by all bidders and auction companies with current fuel prices, insurance costs, online sale fees, etc. While we appreciate your point of view as the collector, your specific review does not seem to be of Garth's and our friendly, informative staff or whether you like and received your delicate shade in good order, but rather the greater auction process in general. Enjoy your shade and we hope, in the end, it reminds you of a positive purchase with Garth's.
AMERICAN QUEZAL ART GLASS SHADE.

Scott
Lafayette, MN

Mar 10, 2023
I was very pleased with the Auction
The overhead was a little high but the return on my investment overshadowed this premium. For example, I sold my coins on eBay for 5 to 6 times what I paid for them with a 15 % discount to my buyers.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Mar 13, 2023
Thank you for your participation and review.
1824 BUST SILVER HALF DOLLAR

Jayson
Sun City Center, FL

Mar 05, 2023
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Mar 06, 2023
Thank you for the review, Jayson. We appreciate your business.
MURCURY HEAD DIME COIN FOLDER.

James
Saline, MI

Mar 04, 2023
Amazing auction company
Amazing auction company with very polite and helpful staff. Highly recommended!!!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Mar 06, 2023
Thank you, James. We appreciate your kind words about our staff.

Jonathan
Sutton, VT

Jan 29, 2023
Excellent!!!
Perfect transaction
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Feb 02, 2023
Thank you for the review!
SIXTEEN PIECES OF GAUDY WELSH.

Jonathan
Sutton, VT

Jan 29, 2023
Excellent!!!
Could not have been any better!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Feb 02, 2023
Thank you, Jonathan!
TWO AMERICAN WROUGHT IRON LOOM LIGHTS.

Michael
Middleburg, PA

Jan 08, 2023
Great Buying Experience!!
The item was received just as advertised. The auction house was very helpful in answering questions. I used Pak Mail for shipping and was extremely satisfied.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jan 10, 2023
Thank you for the great review, Michael.
ENGLISH SCHOOLHOUSE SPATTERWARE PLATE.

Michael
Federal Way, WA

Dec 30, 2022
A GREAT EXPERIENCE
I’ve been wanting to bid and win at Garth’s for quite a while and I won my Auctions and everything was perfect …. HOPE to be a regular.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Jan 03, 2023
Michael-thank you for the shining 5-star review! We appreciate you and hope you will be a regular as well!
SPANISH BRASS CAPSTAN CANDLESTICK.

Cynthia
Fennville, MI

Dec 16, 2022
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Dec 17, 2022
Thank you for the review, Cynthia
PEWTER CANDLESTICK AND TEAPOT.

David
Standish, ME

Dec 16, 2022
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Dec 17, 2022
Thank you for the review, David.
NEW YORK BOARDMAN COMMUNION FLAGON.

Patty
Fredericktown, OH

Dec 14, 2022
Great Auction House
Items were exactly as described, shipping went smoothly, packed excellent.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Dec 15, 2022
Thank you for bidding with us and for the review!
AMERICAN FOLKSY CHEST FORM HANGING WALL BOX.

Kathy
La Porte City, IA

Nov 26, 2022
Steiff St Bernard
Items exactly as described. Love my new Steiff St Bernard. Fit right in with my collection!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Nov 29, 2022
That's great to hear, Kathy. Thank you for the review!

Timothy
Houston, TX

Nov 22, 2022
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Nov 29, 2022
Timothy-do let us know what we-or Amanda Auctions 'team who conducted this sale-can do to earn the other two stars in the future. Thank you!
BLUE MONARK BIKE

Donald Eric
Bridgton, ME

Nov 20, 2022
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Nov 21, 2022
Thank you for the review.
RARE HOMER LAUGHLIN PATE SUR PATE FLOWER VASE.

Kim
Longview, TX

Nov 07, 2022
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Nov 15, 2022
Thank you, Kim

Masahiro
Hillsboro, OR

Nov 06, 2022
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Nov 15, 2022
Thank you for the review!

Martin
Summerville, SC

Oct 31, 2022
Excellent Auction House
Fast Shipment! Excellent Communications! Highly Recommended!!!
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Nov 01, 2022
Thank you, Martin.

Diane
Plattsmouth, NE

Oct 02, 2022
Amish Doll
Nice and professional people to work with.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Oct 06, 2022
Thank you, Diane
AMISH MALE RAG DOLL.

Suzanne
Concord, NC

Sep 29, 2022
Another great auction experience!
Garth's Auction is easy to work with and provides an enjoyable auction experience. The item descriptions are detailed and informative. I am pleased with my dolls. Garth's also offers customers a great third party shipper, The UPS Store # 3435. They pack the items extremely well, have very reasonable shipping costs, get the items shipped quickly, and provide excellent customer service. What a great all-round online auction experience.
Report
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Oct 06, 2022
Suzanne, thank you for your thoughtful review. We are pleased to know we did make your purchasing experience with us a positive one.
TWO GERMAN CHINA HEAD DOLLS.

Cynthia
Bellville, TX

Sep 18, 2022
Garth's Auctions Inc. logo
Garth's Auction Inc.Oct 06, 2022
Thank you, Cynthia!
AMERICAN LOW BACK WINDSOR SETTLE BENCH.
View:
50
iphoneandroidPhone

Get notifications from your favorite auctioneers.

mobilemobile
Garth's Auctions Inc. Online Auctions by:liveauctioneers
Ⓒ 2024 LiveAuctioneers. Terms Privacy
TOP